Monday, October 24, 2011

"Ride Around Missouri: Shelby's Great Raid 1863"

Joseph O. Shelby's "Great Raid" has been the subject of one book length account, Mark Scott's thesis The Fifth Season (Two Trails, 2001). Directed at a general audience as part of Osprey Publishing's Raid series, Sean McLachlan's Ride Around Missouri: Shelby's Great Raid 1863 (2011) is another summary account. Coming in at 80 illustration-filled pages, the book is a typical Osprey offering in length and visual style.

Civil War Missouri was similar to Kentucky in the context of hosting Confederate mounted raids launched from out of state, a major difference being the far more celebrated nature of the Kentucky operations.  McLachlan provides some context in this regard by briefly outlining (and mapping the course of) John S. Marmaduke's 1862-63 Springfield and Cape Girardeau raids that preceded Shelby's own.  Overall, I think the author provides a reasonably good summary of the Great Raid, and its most significant military action -- the October 13 Battle of Marshall. In researching this section, McLachlan consulted the work of historian James Denny, an authority on the battle. A pair of detailed orders of battle (including such information as unit effectives engaged and artillery tube types) and bird's-eye isometric view maps at regiment/battalion/battery scale accompany the Marshall section, with sidebar and main text offering a fairly clear explanation of the fighting's sequence of events. Beyond the maps, the selection of illustrations is unremarkable (I don't recall seeing anything new to my eyes).

In general, Osprey books are meant to be quickly digested popular history and are not presented in a scholarly format; thus the lack of documentation and sparse bibliography require a trusting reader.  I do niggle with some of the material presented. Complaints range from gross errors of fact (e.g. page 7's "After the St. Louis massacre, Governor Jackson easily passed a resolution to secede from the Union") to an overly simplistic (even for a short work such as this) description of the unionist militia system as a dual entity. Given that the various militias were the primary active defenders of Missouri during this period, I would also quibble with McLachlan's conclusion that Shelby's raid (Sept. 22 - Oct. 26, 1863) measurably aided the Army of Tennessee in the West by preventing major troop transfers from Missouri to Tennessee.  These reservations aside, and given the continued dearth of publications dealing with Civil War mounted raids in Missouri, the book is worth a look.


2 comments:

  1. Generally, I have steered clear of Osprey's Civil War titles, with the exception being the Campaign Series' Fair Oaks issue. For the most part, their appeal is to those with a very casual interest in the Civil War who like illustrated histories.

    However, Osprey's Raid Series is producing some interesting titles like this one covering topics one would not expect to find in a popular history format. It seems like a risky marketing decision because, outside of fans of the series who buy every issue, the only other niche for this particular issue would appear to be students of the Trans-Mississippi Theater, who would undoubtedly prefer a scholarly work if available. I have to think Osprey was aware of the dearth of literature on this topic before accepting the title as to insure a market. Hopefully, this issue does well to encourage similar works in the future.

    Chris Van Blargan

    ReplyDelete
  2. Chris,
    I sort of like the Fair Oaks volume, too. The Seven Days one, however, was so bad I returned it.

    ReplyDelete

Blogger ID not required, but if you choose not to create one please sign your post with your name (no promotional information, please). Otherwise, your comment and/or link may be deleted.